When Rim Nam Foods' carton bids came back, two lines from Supplier B stood out. B put 10% more board into the same carton than Supplier A, and it charged more than twice A's rate for set-up. The bid sheet showed the numbers. It couldn't show why.
Some answers you can only get standing next to the machine. Rim Nam's buyer took the plant's production engineer and quality manager to B's factory for a day. By lunchtime they knew where both gaps came from, and that part of the set-up cost was Rim Nam's own doing.
A supplier site visit is a planned walk through the supplier's factory, with a cross-functional team, to see how your product is actually made. Done well, it checks the cost drivers in the bid, tests the supplier against all five drivers, and finds improvements both sides can work on. This post follows the RFP design and spend baseline posts in the series, and it's where Lean and TPM thinking does most of the work.
Supplier site visit checklist: prepare from the bid, walk the process, measure OEE and the six losses, check all five drivers, debrief the same day
What Is a Supplier Site Visit?
Lean has a word for the place where the work happens: gemba. The Lean Enterprise Institute describes a gemba walk as understanding the current situation by observing directly and asking questions before taking action. A supplier site visit applies the same idea to someone else's factory.
It's worth separating three things that often get mixed up:
- An audit checks the supplier against a standard, such as a food safety or quality certification. It answers "do they comply?"
- A sales tour is the supplier showing you what it wants you to see.
- A site visit follows your product through the plant and asks how its cost, quality and delivery are produced. It answers "why does it cost this, and what could make it cost less?"
You need audits. But only the third kind explains a bid line.

Step 1: Prepare From the Bid
A visit without questions turns into a sales tour. Start from the bid sheet and the should-cost model, and list the lines where the supplier differs most from your model or from other bidders. Each one becomes a question to answer on the floor.
Send a short data request a week before, covering:
- Shifts, days worked and headcount on the lines that run your product
- Line speeds and last month's OEE for those lines
- Average changeover time and number of changeovers per week
- Scrap and trim waste as a percentage of input
- Planned maintenance schedule and last quarter's breakdown hours
Then pick the team. Procurement leads, but bring the people who can read what they see: someone from production or engineering, someone from quality, and if possible someone who knows your own demand pattern. Each driver needs its own eyes.
Give each person a part of the process and a short list of questions to own, so four people don't all ask the plant manager the same thing. Send the supplier a simple agenda in advance: a short opening on why you're coming, the floor walk, half an hour each with the people who run operations and quality, and a close-out. If the discussion will touch costs or process know-how, agree a confidentiality agreement before the day, not at the gate.
Two kinds of question are worth preparing carefully:
- Capacity. Ask how much the plant can make in total, not what share of it is yours. It's an easier question to answer, and you can work out your share yourself.
- Your own impact. Ask what in your specification or ordering pattern makes their job harder or more expensive, and whether a standard grade or size would do the same job. Suppliers rarely volunteer this, but most will answer when asked.
And prepare for their questions. Suppliers will ask why you need cost information, what's in it for them, and how the award will be decided. Agree the answers as a team before you go: you're looking for costs you can reduce together, existing contracts will be honoured, and the decision will weigh more than price.
Step 2: Walk the Process in Order
Follow your product from raw material to dispatch, in the order it's made. For a carton that means paper reels arriving, the corrugator, printing and die-cutting, gluing, palletising and the dispatch bay.
At each stage, look at three things before you look at the machine:
- What's waiting. Piles of reels, half-finished board or pallets in the aisle are inventory, and someone pays for it.
- What's being thrown away. Trim, crushed board, misprints.
- What people are doing. Running, waiting, fixing or searching. If operators stand waiting for a machine, or machines stand waiting for operators, the line isn't balanced.
Compare the stock you see with how often trucks come and go. Raw material for three weeks against daily deliveries, or a warehouse full of finished goods against a few shipments a day, means cash tied up and usually an unstable schedule or a lot of downtime behind it.
Look at housekeeping and safety too. Follow the site's safety rules yourself, and notice whether walkways are clear, spills are cleaned up and safety performance is posted. For a food company's packaging supplier, hygiene and pest control around stored board matter as much as on your own site. A tidy, safe floor usually goes with a plant that has its processes under control. It doesn't replace a formal food safety or quality audit.
Then ask the operators, not just the plant manager. They know how often the line stops and why.
Step 3: Measure What Drives the Cost
The paper in a carton follows a published index. The rest of the price doesn't. ResourceWise notes that energy, freight, maintenance and labour together can cost more than the paper for some box types, and those are the costs a supplier will point to next. With Thai fuel prices up 29.18% year on year in October 2026, expect energy surcharge letters. The best answer to one is knowing how efficiently the plant uses its machines, people and energy, and you can see most of that on the floor.
TPM gives you a ready-made checklist for it. The Lean Enterprise Institute defines overall equipment effectiveness as availability rate × performance rate × quality rate, and lists six losses that pull it down:
- Breakdowns
- Machine adjustments, including set-ups
- Brief stops
- Running below design speed
- Scrap
- Rework
On the floor, check which of the six you can actually see on the line that runs your product. Then compare it with the OEE figure on the supplier's board or in the data request. If the board says 80% and the line stopped three times while you watched, ask about it.
You can test the numbers with simple arithmetic. Time one machine cycle, work out what a full shift at that speed would produce, and compare it with the plant's actual output per shift. The gap is the losses. Then ask the supervisor for the top causes of downtime and scrap. A plant that can show you a ranked list, with actions against each, knows where its money goes. Pick up a scrap ticket if you see one: if the date is old and nobody can explain the cause, nobody is working on it.
Three more checks I always make:
- Changeovers. Time one if you can. The SMED method developed by Shigeo Shingo splits set-up work into internal tasks that need the machine stopped and external tasks that can be done while it runs. If operators fetch plates and dies after the machine stops, the set-up line in the bid has room to fall.
- Maintenance. Look for current maintenance schedules, cleaning and inspection checklists at the machines, and how breakdowns are logged. A plant that only fixes what breaks will charge you for it.
- Visual management. Are performance boards up to date? A board last updated three weeks ago tells you the numbers aren't being used.
Step 4: Check the Other Four Drivers
Cost is only one of the five drivers. Use the same day to check the rest:
- Quality. Visit the quality lab. Look at test records for your product (for cartons, compression and crush tests) and how out-of-spec batches are handled.
- Service. Check spare capacity, finished-goods stock and what happens if the main line goes down. Is there a second machine, or a sister plant?
- Innovation. Ask to see the design or sample room. Ask what they've changed for other customers in the last year.
- Continuous improvement. Ask what improvement projects are running and what they've delivered. A supplier with a real improvement program shows you results. One without it shows you a poster.
Each of these feeds the supplier relationship long after the contract is signed.
Step 5: Debrief the Same Day
Sit down as a team before you leave the area, while it's fresh. Go back to the questions from Step 1 and answer each one: confirmed, explained, or still open. Update the should-cost model with what you learned. Then sort the findings into two lists:
- Questions for the clarification meeting, each linked to a bid line.
- Improvements to work on together, some of which may sit on your side, not the supplier's.
Put a rough value on each improvement idea and agree who follows it up. Note the questions you couldn't answer; they're the agenda for the next visit, or for an expert who knows the industry's typical yields and speeds.
Share a short summary with the supplier. A visit that ends in silence feels like an inspection. One that ends in a joint improvement list starts a relationship.
What Did Rim Nam's Visit Show?
The visit to Supplier B's plant explained both gaps (illustrative findings):
| Bid line | What the floor showed | What followed |
| 10% more board per carton | An older corrugator with frequent warp. B used heavier liners to keep the cartons flat. | B planned a corrugator upgrade; a lighter board trial was set for after the fix. |
| Set-up charge 2.7× Supplier A | Printer changeovers took around 70 minutes, mostly with the machine stopped. Rim Nam's 14 carton print variants came in small weekly runs. | B started a changeover project. Rim Nam cut print variants from 14 to 8 and moved to fortnightly orders. |
| OEE "about 75%" on the board | The team counted three stops in two hours; B's own data put the carton line nearer 55%. | Availability became a standing item in the quarterly supplier review. |
The second line was the surprise. Part of the high set-up charge came from Rim Nam's own ordering pattern, so the fix needed operations and marketing on Rim Nam's side as much as engineers on B's. That's the cross-functional point from the duties map post in practice.
Back to the two bid lines. The buyer who negotiates them from the desk gets a discount on the set-up charge and the same 70-minute changeovers. The buyer who walked the floor gets a lower cost that stays down, and a supplier working on the next improvement.
A Key Point for me is always "know and understand how the product you buy is made, that way you have a better understanding of the cost drivers".
If you are a supply chain person you can also apply this to your own factory as a good staring point to drive cost saving and improvement initiatives.
Remember we follow Rim Nam Foods, a made-up curry maker outside Bangkok
I'm not good with Graphic Design, all the images are AI generated.