Skip to Content

Supply Market Analysis

How to Read a Supplier Market Before You Go to Tender

Rim Nam Foods' carton contract comes up for renewal in six months. The buyer knows her suppliers well by now. She has their cost breakdowns, she's walked Supplier B's factory floor, and an index clause already moves the paper line. But three questions on her desk have nothing to do with any one supplier. Should she lock in two years or one? Is now a good time to tender, or should she wait? And is relying on one converter for every carton still a sensible risk?

Those are questions about the market, not the supplier. Supply market analysis is how you answer them. It means understanding the market your suppliers buy and sell in: how their costs are built, who the players are, what moves prices and who holds the power. The output we use is a one-page market fact sheet, built before the tender, that shapes who you invite, how long you contract for and what you index to.

This post continues the series after RFP design and the supplier site visit. Those two looked inside one supplier. This one looks at the market around all of them.

Supply market analysis: a one-page market fact sheet covering cost structure, players and capacity, price drivers and power, turned into tender decisions

What Is Supply Market Analysis?

CIPS places market analysis at the second stage of its procurement cycle and describes it as assessing market conditions, trends and risks to shape sourcing strategy and manage bargaining power. It covers market structure, supply and demand, substitutes, and currency and commodity trends.

For a single category, I boil that down to a one-page fact sheet that answers five questions, built in six steps:

  1. How is the supplier's cost built? Which inputs drive the price, one level upstream as well as at the supplier.
  2. Who supplies, and how much capacity is there? The number of players at each level, who owns whom, and how full the plants are.
  3. Where is demand going? Whether your suppliers' other customers are buying more or less.
  4. What moves the price? The indices, the lags between them, and currency.
  5. Who holds the power? Whether the market favours buyers or sellers right now, and why.

Answer those five and the tender strategy mostly writes itself. Skip them and you're tendering on habit.

Step 1: Start From the Cost Structure

You already have most of this if you built a should-cost model in Part 1 of the series. In Rim Nam's case, board accounts for THB 6.73 of the THB 11.13 carton price, about 60%.

Market analysis takes that one level further back. A box converter buys containerboard. A containerboard mill making recycled grades buys recovered paper, mostly old corrugated containers (OCC), plus energy for its dryers and boilers. So the chain behind Rim Nam's carton is: recovered paper and energy, then containerboard, then the converter, then the box.

Draw that chain for your own category. It tells you which markets to watch, and it explains why a box price can move when nothing at your converter has changed.

Step 2: Define the Market, Then Map the Players

Start by deciding how wide the market is, because each level of the chain has a different boundary. Cartons are bulky and cheap to make, so converters compete within trucking distance of your plant. Containerboard travels further and trades across the region. Recovered paper is a global commodity. Get the boundary wrong and you'll count the wrong competitors.

Then count the players at each level, because the power usually sits where there are fewest.

For cartons in Thailand, there are many converters, often with several within delivery distance of a plant like Rim Nam's. There are far fewer containerboard mills, and some of the big groups own converters too. That matters: if your converter buys its board from a mill that also runs competing box plants, its board price and its competitors' are not set at arm's length.

Then look at capacity against demand. When mills run well below full, they compete for volume and prices soften. Fastmarkets RISI described Asian containerboard as oversupplied, with Chinese containerboard mills running at an estimated 65% to 78% in 2024, and expected new capacity in Indonesia in 2026 or 2027 to keep producers hunting for buyers. Capacity is also moving closer to ASEAN demand. Regional producers are extending their footprint into Vietnam and Malaysia and adding recovered-fibre lines in Indonesia.

Step 3: Forecast Supply and Demand

A snapshot tells you where the market is. A forecast tells you where it's heading over the life of your contract, and that's what decides contract length.

Start with this year's balance. Statisticians measure a country's use of a product as apparent consumption: production plus imports minus exports, and the same arithmetic works for a supply market. Compare it with capacity to get today's utilisation. Then add the capacity suppliers have announced, mill by mill and year by year, and set it against a realistic demand growth rate.

What you're looking for is the direction. When announced capacity outruns demand, the market goes long: suppliers chase volume and prices soften, which favours shorter contracts or longer ones with a two-way index. When demand catches up with capacity, the market goes short, and securing supply matters more than squeezing price. Get the starting year right before you project anything, and sanity-check the result against what suppliers tell you.

For cartons, the picture today points long at the regional level. Alongside the surplus in Step 2, CLSA's October note on one of Thailand's major packaging groups said Thai packaging demand was weak while Vietnam and Indonesia were picking up. Soft local demand with spare regional capacity is, on paper, a buyer's market at the converter level.

Most of the data is public. For Thailand, the Ministry of Commerce publishes import and export statistics by HS code, which covers recovered paper (HS 4707), containerboard grades (HS 4804 and 4805) and boxes (HS 4819). Listed suppliers' annual reports give capacity, utilisation and expansion plans. Trade press, price reporters and analyst notes fill in the rest, and supplier interviews and site visits tell you what the numbers miss.

Step 4: Track What Moves the Price

Pick the two or three indices that drive the cost chain and follow them monthly. For cartons, that means a containerboard price, a recovered paper price and energy.

Watch the gap between them as well as the levels. The same CLSA note shows regional testliner barely moving in the third quarter of 2026, from USD 406 to 409 a tonne, while American OCC rose from USD 169 to 183. When the input rises and the output doesn't, the mills' margin is being squeezed, and they'll try to pass it on. The note expects the effect to show with a lag.

The recovered paper market explains why. The BIR's June report on recovered paper said Southeast Asian prices rose 5% to 10% in April and May, after the Middle East conflict pushed up freight and energy, and noted that China's halt of recycled pulp imports in late 2025 shifted more fibre demand towards the region. Thai fuel prices were up 29.18% year on year in October 2026.

Two practical points. First, know the lags: a move in recovered paper reaches board prices weeks or months later, and box prices after that. Second, check the currency. Board and recovered paper trade in dollars, so a weaker baht raises your cost even when the index stands still.

Step 5: Judge Who Holds the Power, and How Suppliers Will Act

Michael Porter's five forces give a useful structure here, read from the buyer's side:

  1. Supplier concentration. Few mills, many converters: your converter has less power than its board supplier.
  2. Your importance to the supplier. What share of the converter's volume are you? Ask about total plant capacity on your site visit and work it out.
  3. Switching costs. Print plates, line trials and quality approval all make changing supplier slower. Know how long it would take you.
  4. Substitutes. For export cartons there are few, but specification changes such as a lighter board count as one.
  5. New entrants. New regional capacity and converters adding plants give you options you didn't have two years ago.

Two of Porter's conditions are worth checking against your own position. Harvard's Institute for Strategy and Competitiveness notes that buyers have most power when they're large relative to sellers, the product is undifferentiated and a significant cost, and switching is cheap. And rivalry between suppliers is fiercest when growth is slow and fixed costs and exit barriers are high. Paper mills fit that description: a paper machine is a huge fixed cost, capacity arrives in big steps, and mills rarely close quickly. That's why containerboard prices tend to swing in cycles.

The five forces describe the market as it stands. To anticipate what suppliers will do next, it helps to think in the older industrial-economics chain of structure, conduct and performance, an approach most associated with the economist Joe Bain. Changes in market structure, such as new capacity, a merger or an energy shock, change how suppliers behave: they cut or raise prices, close old machines, buy competitors or integrate forwards into converting. Their profits then shift, which feeds back into the next round of decisions. Asking "if this changes, what will the mills do, and what will that do to my converter?" turns the fact sheet from a description into a forecast.

If you've used the Kraljic matrix, this is the detail behind its supply-risk axis. My dual-lens post on Kraljic and Kenton covers how to place a category once you know where the power sits.

Step 6: Turn It Into Tender Decisions

The fact sheet earns its place by changing decisions. Before the tender, use it to agree five things with the category team:

  1. Who to invite. Include at least one supplier that isn't tied to a mill, and any new capacity within reach.
  2. Contract length. In a soft market, a longer contract locks in a good price only if an index clause lets it fall as well as rise.
  3. What to index to. Board alone, or board plus an energy review with a threshold, depending on what drives your supplier's cost.
  4. Timing. Tender while the market favours you, and before a known price push reaches your suppliers.
  5. Supply risk. Decide whether one supplier is still acceptable, given capacity, logistics and the cost of switching.

This is where cost stops being the only driver in the conversation. Capacity and logistics risk are about service. Who is investing in new lines and lighter grades is about innovation. A market view keeps all of them in the tender.

Then keep the sheet alive. Start with what you already know internally and a few hypotheses, rather than waiting for perfect data. Refresh the indices monthly and the rest at least once a year. And bring the market into supplier meetings: asking a supplier how it sees capacity and prices moving tells you as much about its plans as about the market.

What Did Rim Nam's Market Fact Sheet Show?

Rim Nam's buyer built the sheet in two weeks with input from finance and operations (illustrative findings):

QuestionFindingTender decision
Cost structureBoard is about 60% of the carton; board cost follows recovered paper and energyKeep the paper index; add an energy review above a 10% move
Market and playersConverters compete within trucking distance; board trades regionally; several converters within reachInvite two converters not owned by a mill
Supply and demandRegional board capacity in surplus with more announced; Thai demand soft; converters keen for volumeTwo-year contract with a two-way index; tender now rather than after the year-end restock
Price driversRecovered paper rising faster than board; mill margins squeezedLock the starting price before mills push increases through
Power and riskOne converter supplies everything; flood delays hit Thai deliveries this yearAward 80/20 and qualify a second source

The last row is the start of the next job: finding and qualifying that second supplier, which is where the series goes next.

Back to the three questions on her desk. The buyer who tenders without reading the market signs another one-year deal, at whatever price lands, just before the mills push their increase through. The buyer with a fact sheet tenders while converters want volume, locks a starting price with a two-way index, and has a second supplier ready before the next flood.

Remember we follow Rim Nam Foods, a made-up curry maker outside Bangkok

I'm not good with Graphic Design, all the images are AI generated. 

How to Read a Factory Floor Before You Negotiate
Supplier Site Visit Checklist